If you have seen the film of Dead Man Walking, how did its approach to the issue of capital punishment differ from that of the book?Did you feel that the filmmaker was taking sides on the issue, or did he treat both sides in a balanced way?
If you have seen the film of Dead Man Walking, how did its approach to the issue of capital punishment differ from that of the book?Did you feel that the filmmaker was taking sides on the issue, or did he treat both sides in a balanced way?Tags: Youtube Channel Business PlanMaryknoll Society EssayEugene Smith Photo Essay Country DoctorAssignment WritersQuotes On Creative WritingPersonal Theory Paper LibertyDivorce Case Studies
Sister Helen quotes Albert Camus on the death penalty: "To assert..a man must be absolutely cut off from society because he is absolutely evil amounts to saying that society is absolutely good, and no one in his right mind will believe this today" [p. Do you feel this is an accurate view of government, or do you feel that the government we have does reflect, at least in large part, the opinions of its citizens?
If so, do you think that it is the government's job to educate and lead public opinion or to follow it?
How do the lives, expectations, and attitudes of the members of Survive differ from those of the members of the group founded by the Harveys?
What do these differences tell us about the lives of black Louisianans as opposed to white ones?
Doesn't the moral foundation of a society erode if its government is allowed to treat these fundamental, nonnegotiable rights as some sort of privilege, which they take on themselves to dispense for good behavior or withdraw for bad behavior? Sister Helen describes the legal system as "a system of gates that shut like one-way turnstiles, and you can't go back once you've come out" [p. The long appeals process would seem to ensure a fair trial for all, but in actuality the prisoner's success within it depends upon how good a lawyer he can afford to hire.
Has the experience of reading Dead Man Walking changed your views of the American legal system, and, if so, in what way?
Sister Helen asks Phelps his opinions on some questions that have been bothering her.
"Aren't there, I argue, some rights fundamental to human beings-- such as the right not to be tortured or killed-- that everyone, including governments, must respect? Do you agree with Sister Helen that, according to Amnesty International's definition of torture, Pat Sonnier was tortured?
While reading the book, did you find yourself looking upon Sister Helen as a heroine?
Lloyd Leblanc asks Sister Helen, "How can you present Elmo Patrick Sonnier's side like this without ever having come to visit with me and my wife or the Bourques to hear our side? 64] Why do you think it never occurred to Sister Helen to do this?